✦ Shifty Estimate
$240,300
▲ 1.7% · 12 mo- 12 months median
- $213K
- Market cap
- $2.4B · 10,000 built
- Sales, 12 months
- 15
- For sale now
- 52
- Original MSRP
- $239,350 · ▲ 0% since
Track this car in the app
Get its live Shifty Estimate, price alerts, and every sale on your phone.
2009 Ferrari 458 Italia
2009 to 2015 · Coupe · 10,000 built
Price history
Recent sales
15 sales on file
The full sale history lives in the app.
Every sale for this exact market, with the chassis behind each number. Drop your email and you are first in.
For sale now
2012 · White · 16,216 mi · Young Motorcars
2012 · Rosso Mugello · 13,187 mi · Mark Motors
2014 · Red · 8,841 mi · Earth MotorCars
2012 · Red · 12,667 mi · Cleveland Motorsports
2010 · Silver · 7,028 mi · Ferrari of Salt Lake City
2011 · Grigio Silverstone Metallic · 19,464 mi · Ferrari Philadelphia
Specifications
- Engine
- Naturally Aspirated V8, 4.5L
- Power
- 570 hp
- Torque
- 398 lb-ft
- 0 to 60
- 3.3s
- Top speed
- 202 mph
- Transmission
- Dual-Clutch (PDK / DCT / DSG)
- Drivetrain
- RWD
- Curb weight
- 3,274 lb
- Production
- 10,000 units
- Original MSRP
- $239,350
- Designer
- Flavio Manzoni
Common questions
How much does a Ferrari 458 Italia cost?
A 2009 Ferrari 458 Italia cost $239,350 new. Over the past 12 months, 15 have sold publicly at a median of $213,000. The Shifty Estimate for a well-kept example is $240,300. Cars have changed hands anywhere from $151,252 to $290,876, depending on mileage, color, and history.
What is a 2009 Ferrari 458 Italia worth today?
The Shifty Estimate is $240,300, up 1.7% over the past 12 months. Confidence is high: 15 public sales in a year gives a firm read.
Is a Ferrari 458 Italia a good investment?
It has appreciated 0% against its $239,350 list price. Values are up 1.7% over the past 12 months. Only 10,000 were built. The caution is spread, not direction: across the sales we have on file, prices ran from $80,000 to $450,000, and mileage explains most of that.
What has a Ferrari 458 Italia sold for at auction?
The 3 most recent public sales we have on file:
- $80,000Jul 29, 2026dark-red · 35,514 mi
- $285,919Jul 28, 2026Black · 28,000 mi
- $450,000Jul 21, 2026Rosso Corsa · 4,300 mi
The 458 Italia represents Ferrari's masterpiece of naturally aspirated engineering, widely considered the greatest V8 Ferrari ever built. Flavio Manzoni's design perfectly balances aggression with elegance, while the 4.5-liter V8 produces 570 horsepower with a 9,000 rpm redline that sounds absolutely intoxicating. The seven-speed dual-clutch transmission shifts faster than any human could manage, yet maintains the emotional connection often lost in modern supercars. Advanced aerodynamics and electronic systems make it surprisingly accessible while delivering genuine supercar performance—0-60 in 3.3 seconds and 202 mph top speed. With 10,000 units produced, it's not rare, but represents the end of an era before turbocharging arrived. Clean examples are appreciating as collectors recognize this as Ferrari's final naturally aspirated V8 masterpiece. The 458 Italia perfectly bridges analog emotion with digital precision.