2009 Ferrari 458 Italia

How much does a Ferrari 458 Italia cost?

A 2009 Ferrari 458 Italia cost $239,350 new. Over the past 12 months, 29 have sold publicly at a median of $219,179. The Shifty Estimate for a well-kept example is $294,300. Cars have changed hands anywhere from $140,926 to $338,445, depending on mileage, color, and history.

What is a 2009 Ferrari 458 Italia worth today?

The Shifty Estimate is $294,300, up 6.3% over the past 12 months. That sits above the $219,179 median of actual sales because the median counts every car that sold, including high-mileage examples, while the estimate describes a clean, low-mileage one bought today. Confidence is high: 29 public sales in a year gives a firm read.

Is a Ferrari 458 Italia a good investment?

It has appreciated 23% against its $239,350 list price. Values are up 6.3% over the past 12 months. Only 10,000 were built. The caution is spread, not direction: across the sales we have on file, prices ran from $118,500 to $501,000, and mileage explains most of that.

What has a Ferrari 458 Italia sold for at auction?

The 3 most recent public sales we have on file:

• $315,000Sep 3, 2026White · 19,198 mi
• $219,179Aug 23, 2026Argento Nurburgring · 28,069 mi
• $501,000Aug 19, 2026Bianco Avus · 1,800 mi