✦ Shifty Estimate
$31,900
▼ 10.5% · 12 mo- 12 months median
- $33K
- Sales, 12 months
- 25
- For sale now
- 23
- Original MSRP
- $90,200 · ▼ 65% since
Track this car in the app
Get its live Shifty Estimate, price alerts, and every sale on your phone.
2011 BMW M5
2011 to 2016 · Sedan
Price history
Recent sales
28 sales
2013 · Alpine White · 108,100 mi · automatic2026-09-03 · shadowede$14,750
2013 · Silverstone Metallic · 48,000 mi · manual2026-08-19 · jj42$45,000
2016 · Monte Carlo Blue Metallic · 65,300 mi · automatic2026-08-17 · gearhead9$38,250
2013 · Amazonite Silver Metallic · 85,600 mi · manual2026-08-03 · LeCarzz$40,250
2014 · Alpine White · 8,000 mi · manual2026-07-09 · farhan270$86,000
2013 · Singapore Gray Metallic · 66,700 mi · automatic2026-07-08 · alesny$22,222
2014 · Singapore Gray Metallic · 52,000 mi · automatic2026-07-07 · DolanMotorCo$29,750
2013 · Monte Carlo Blue Metallic · 51,900 mi · automatic2026-07-01 · BroncoBoy$27,250
2013 · Azurite Black Metallic · 70,000 mi · manual2026-06-30 · sm4450$28,000
2015 · Imperial Blue Metallic · 85,600 mi · manual2026-06-26 · Yahmac$37,500
2013 · Azurite Blue Metallic · 70,500 mi · automatic2026-06-24 · thegreatmandito$35,500
2013 · Black Sapphire Metallic · 103,000 mi · manual2026-06-17 · bstaller$20,900
2016 · Silverstone Metallic · 100,000 mi · automatic2026-06-15 · TurboDave$25,250
2013 · Silverstone Metallic · 163,800 mi · automatic2026-06-08 · cltchris$14,000
2014 · Silverstone Metallic · 51,000 mi · manual2026-05-20 · shopclubsautogroup$51,000
2013 · Alpine White · 35,000 mi2026-03-25 · cncar640$43,000
2015 · Singapore Gray Metallic · 33,000 mi · automatic2026-03-18 · TDOTMA$39,750
2013 · Silverstone Metallic · 114,100 mi · automatic2026-03-12 · autoonly1$19,250
2015 · Azurite Black Metallic · 52,000 mi · automatic2026-02-24 · MohrImports$34,000
2013 · Monte Carlo Blue Metallic · 95,600 mi · automatic2026-02-24 · miniman181$16,000
2015 · Black Sapphire Metallic · 37,000 mi · automatic2026-02-18 · 2FAM$41,500
2013 · Monte Carlo Blue Metallic · 47,100 mi · automatic2026-02-17 · Boostadict1984$29,000
2015 · Silverstone Metallic · 48,000 mi2026-01-30 · rka0507$51,500
2013 · Sakhir Orange Metallic · 41,000 mi · automatic2026-01-21 · Husam21$33,250
2014 · Monte Carlo Blue Metallic · 86,000 mi · automatic2026-01-08 · bikerdude2k$23,000
2012 · Blue · 76,745 mi · other2025-01-19 · Private Seller$16,767
2013 · Monte Carlo Blue · 79,000 mi · other2024-09-18$18,754- 2013 · IMPERIAL BLUE METALLIC · automatic2024-04-19$34,100
For sale now
23 listings
2013 · Grey · 128,991 mi · Logic Motors$21,999
2015 · Black · 63,145 mi · Topline Auto Group$37,190
2015 · Alpine White · 88,978 mi · Auto Star Motors$34,890
2013 · 126,626 mi · American Motors LLC$20,995
2014 · ORANGE · 47,949 mi · PurMotive$44,395
2016 · Black Sapphire Metallic · 98,695 mi · Ruby Mountain Motors - Twin Falls$28,999
2014 · Singapore Gray Metallic · 102,148 mi · BMW of Tigard$24,940
2014 · Alpine White · 65,433 mi · Chicago Auto Sports$43,177
2014 · Silverstone Metallic · 73,773 mi · Bommarito St. Peters$31,271
2015 · Black Sapphire Metallic · 86,275 mi · Motor Cars of Chicago$29,353
2013 · Silver · 86,122 mi · HD Auto Sales Corp.$25,199
2014 · Black · 45,333 mi · BMW of Fort Walton Beach$33,516
2013 · Alpine White Metallic · 43,370 mi · Right Buy Auto$34,869
2014 · Gray · 75,157 mi · AP Fairfax$26,995
2014 · Space Gray Metallic · 92,769 mi · Bay Motorsports, LLC$23,900
2016 · Black Sapphire Metallic · 66,724 mi · Leif Johnson Ford of Austin$33,843
2016 · Monte Carlo Blue Metallic · 63,571 mi · Auto Star Motors$39,991
2013 · YAS MARINA BLUE · 59,717 mi · West State Motorsport$42,426
2014 · Gray · 67,063 mi · Denver Auto Sales$37,000
2015 · 83,584 mi · Pierre Ford of Lynnwood$29,991
2013 · White · 68,000 mi · Euro Auto Boutique$26,999
2013 · Gray · 61,308 mi · Direct Auto Sales $31,392
2013 · Space Gray Metallic · 107,661 mi · Perry Ford of Santa Barbara$21,860
Specifications
- Engine
- V8 Twin-Turbo, 4.4L Twin-Turbo
- Power
- 560 hp
- Torque
- 500 lb-ft
- 0 to 60
- 4.4s
- Top speed
- 155 mph
- Transmission
- Dual-Clutch (PDK / DCT / DSG)
- Drivetrain
- RWD
- Original MSRP
- $90,200
Common questions
How much does a BMW M5 cost?
A 2011 BMW M5 cost $90,200 new. Over the past 12 months, 25 have sold publicly at a median of $33,250. The Shifty Estimate for a well-kept example is $31,900. Cars have changed hands anywhere from $16,383 to $44,000, depending on mileage, color, and history.
What is a 2011 BMW M5 worth today?
The Shifty Estimate is $31,900, down 10.5% over the past 12 months. Confidence is high: 25 public sales in a year gives a firm read.
Is a BMW M5 a good investment?
It has depreciated 65% against its $90,200 list price. Values are down 10.5% over the past 12 months. The caution is spread, not direction: across the sales we have on file, prices ran from $14,000 to $86,000, and mileage explains most of that.
What has a BMW M5 sold for at auction?
The 3 most recent public sales we have on file:
- $14,750Sep 3, 2026Alpine White · 108,100 mi
- $45,000Aug 19, 2026Silverstone Metallic · 48,000 mi
- $38,250Aug 17, 2026Monte Carlo Blue Metallic · 65,300 mi
The F10 M5 marked BMW's controversial but brilliant shift from naturally aspirated V10 to twin-turbo V8 power. This 4.4-liter S63 engine delivered 560 horsepower and 502 lb-ft of torque, making it the most powerful M5 ever at launch. What seemed like heresy to purists proved transformative—the twin-turbo setup provided massive mid-range punch while maintaining the M5's signature four-door practicality. The seven-speed dual-clutch transmission replaced the beloved manual, though it delivered lightning-quick shifts that complemented the engine's character. BMW's Active M Differential and adjustable suspension kept the handling sharp despite the added weight. Production ran through 2016, with later Competition Package cars being particularly sought after. While initially divisive among enthusiasts, the F10 has aged remarkably well, offering supercar performance in executive sedan clothing. Clean examples with service records are becoming increasingly desirable as collectors recognize this generation's significance in M5 evolution.