Market study
Same car, sold twice
We followed 2,411 collector cars that sold at auction, then sold again at the same house. 46% sold for more the second time. The typical car came back 2.0% lower, after a median 1.3 years.
- Sold for more
- 46%
- Of 2,515 resales at the same auction house
- Typical change
- −2.0%
- Median, second sale against the first, kept 1.3 years
- Kept 5 years or more
- 68%
- Sold for more, typically +24.5%, on 113 resales
Time is what separates them. Sold again within three years, fewer than half made money. Kept five years or more, two in three did, and the typical one came back 24.5% higher. What a car cost made little difference: from under $30,000 to over $200,000, the typical change stayed between −3.4% and 0.0%.
By how long it was kept
A quick resale usually gives a little back. A long one usually gains. 2,142 of the 2,515 resales came within three years, which is why the overall figure sits just below zero.
The change, by how long it was kept
Collector cars sold twice at the same auction house, 2016 to October 2026 · Shifty sales records
Median change from the first sale price to the second. Dollars as sold, not adjusted for inflation.
See the figures
| Kept | Median change | Sold for more | Resales |
|---|---|---|---|
| Under 1 year | −2.9% | 43% | 939 |
| 1 to 3 years | −2.8% | 44% | 1,203 |
| 3 to 5 years | +5.0% | 55% | 260 |
| 5 years or more | +24.5% | 68% | 113 |
By make
We put a number on a make once it has 40 resales in the study. 18 makes clear it. Ferrari, Toyota, Honda, Mazda and Nissan came back higher more often than not. Land Rover and Bentley rarely did.
The change, make by make
Makes with at least 40 resales, most resales first · Shifty sales records
Median change from the first sale price to the second. A make appears once it has 40 resales in the study.
See the figures
| Make | Median change | Sold for more | Resales |
|---|---|---|---|
| Every car in the study | −2.0% | 46% | 2,515 |
| Ferrari | +7.8% | 64% | 318 |
| Mercedes-Benz | −6.3% | 38% | 263 |
| Porsche | −0.6% | 46% | 209 |
| Jaguar | −7.8% | 36% | 181 |
| Chevrolet | −3.2% | 42% | 164 |
| Ford | −4.5% | 37% | 142 |
| Aston Martin | −6.4% | 34% | 137 |
| Dodge | −1.1% | 46% | 134 |
| Toyota | +3.3% | 54% | 126 |
| Alfa Romeo | −6.5% | 41% | 88 |
| Audi | −3.1% | 46% | 79 |
| BMW | −0.9% | 44% | 61 |
| Honda | +8.9% | 65% | 60 |
| Mazda | +2.6% | 58% | 60 |
| Cadillac | −5.2% | 41% | 54 |
| Nissan | +7.5% | 61% | 51 |
| Land Rover | −23.5% | 12% | 49 |
| Bentley | −9.8% | 22% | 45 |
Two cars, both sales
Every resale in the study is one chassis, matched by its VIN or chassis number. One was kept for years and one was sold again within a year, the two patterns the study found. Both are checked by hand against both sale pages.
1998 Ferrari F355 Spider
VINZFFXR48A5W0111582- First sale
- $62,000
- Second sale
- $160,000
- Change
- +158.1%
2024 Porsche 992 GT3 RS
VINWP0AF2A96RS273134- First sale
- $398,000
- Second sale
- $345,000
- Change
- −13.3%
How we worked it out
We started from every collector car on file that sold at auction more than once, matched by its VIN or chassis number. A resale counts when both sales happened at the same auction house, at least 90 days apart, and both records name the same make and model year. That leaves 2,515 resales of 2,411 cars across 8 houses.
Same house matters. Some houses publish prices with the buyer’s fee and some without, so a car that moves house can look like it gained when it did not. The 758 resales that moved house sold for more 54% of the time, typically +3.1%. We left them out rather than guess at each fee.
Prices are in dollars as sold, with no adjustment for inflation. We set aside any pair where the second price is under a quarter or over four times the first, since that is almost always a different car or a bad record, not a market move. Every five-year hold began in 2021 or earlier, so that figure carries the market of those years with it.
A car that comes back to auction is a car its owner chose to sell. That is not every car, and an owner who did well may be readier to sell. Read these numbers as what happened to cars that came back, not as a forecast for yours.
Figures as of October 28, 2026. Auction sales only, prices in USD.
Know what your car would bring today
Shifty prices your car from real sales, and keeps its VIN’s full sale history. One car, free.